LawQuorum

Home › News › Aadhaar Not Conclusive Proof of Age, Postmortem Report More Reliable: Madhya Pradesh High Court

Aadhaar Not Conclusive Proof of Age, Postmortem Report More Reliable: Madhya Pradesh High Court

12 Nov 2026 · Legal News · By LawQuorum

The Madhya Pradesh High Court has ruled that an Aadhaar card is an identity document and cannot, on its own, be treated as conclusive proof of the age of its holder. The court said a postmortem report, which records a medical opinion on age, is a more reliable basis for determining the age of a deceased person.

The observation came while the court was hearing an appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The appellants-claimants had sought enhancement of the compensation awarded by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, which had granted Rs 5,45,000 with interest for the death of a minor, Harendra Singh Baghel, in a motor accident.

Justice Amit Seth, sitting in a Single Bench, noted that the Claims Tribunal had relied on the Aadhaar card to determine the deceased's age as 14 years, 7 months and 9 days. However, the postmortem report (Ex.P10), which contains a medical opinion on age, recorded it as 13 years. The court held that the age in the postmortem report, based on a medical assessment during the postmortem examination, was more reliable in the facts of the case. It accordingly took the deceased's age as 13 years at the time of the accident.

The appellants had argued that the deceased was a minor and that the notional income should have been based on the minimum wages payable to an unskilled workman on the date of the accident, which was Rs 7,950 per month, instead of the Rs 25,000 per month determined by the Tribunal. Relying on the Madhya Pradesh State Legal Services Authority (MPSLSA) Guidelines, the court accepted the monthly income of Rs 7,950, making the annual income Rs 95,400.

Since the deceased was below 15 years of age, the court held that the appropriate multiplier was 15, not 18 as applied by the Tribunal. The court also awarded Rs 40,000 each to the appellants-claimants towards loss of parental consortium, totalling Rs 80,000, along with Rs 15,000 for funeral expenses and Rs 15,000 for loss of estate.

The court thus held the appellants-claimants entitled to a total compensation of Rs 8,25,500, as against Rs 5,45,000 awarded by the Tribunal, and said they were entitled to an enhanced compensation of Rs 2,80,500. The appeal was partly allowed. Advocate Dharmendra Rishishwar represented the appellants-claimants, while Advocate Bal Krishna Agrawal appeared for the respondent Insurance Company.

Source: Verdictum