Bombay High Court Refuses Urgent Permission for Chhath Puja at Girgaum Chowpatty
The Bombay High Court has declined to grant urgent permission for Chhath Puja celebrations at Mumbai's Girgaum Chowpatty on November 15 and 16. A vacation bench of Justice Advait M Sethna and Justice Ranjitsinha Raja Bhonsale observed that the fundamental right to religious freedom under Article 25 of the Constitution is subject to the requirements of public order, morality and health.
The bench was hearing a petition filed by the Mithila Chhath Puja Sangh, which sought permission to erect a temporary stage and make arrangements for the festivities at the beach between 3 pm on November 15 and 8 am on November 16. The Court said that while Article 25 guarantees freedom of conscience and the right to profess, practise and propagate religion, this freedom cannot be exercised independently of the safeguards prescribed by the Constitution. It noted that the constitutional framework incorporates checks and balances that must be respected when seeking permission to organise public religious events.
The Sangh had approached the High Court after the concerned police station rejected its request through a communication dated September 17. The police cited existing High Court directions under which a high-powered committee supervises activities and events at Girgaum Chowpatty. Under the prevailing restrictions, permissions at the beach are confined to specified celebrations, including Ganeshotsav, Navratri Utsav, Ramlila, Krishnalila and Christmas. Other programmes require the requisite approvals from the concerned authorities.
The petitioner told the Court that it had also submitted a representation to the Maharashtra Chief Minister on October 7, seeking permission to organise the Chhath Puja celebrations, but no decision had been taken on it yet. Opposing the plea, the State government relied on the High Court's earlier directions in Adarsh Chowpatty Pragati Mandal and Others v. State of Maharashtra. Under an interim order dated June 21, 2018, activities at Girgaum Chowpatty were required to remain confined to a designated area measuring 300 x 150 square feet. The earlier directions also stipulated that the court-appointed Monitoring Committee must be impleaded in proceedings concerning permissions for events or the erection of temporary structures at the beach.
During the hearing, the bench questioned the petitioner about compliance with these requirements, particularly whether the Monitoring Committee had granted the necessary permission and had been made a party to the proceedings. The Court recorded that the petitioner's counsel had no satisfactory response on the issue. The bench consequently declined to grant the requested interim relief. It also refused to issue directions to the authorities to identify or allot an alternative venue for the religious celebrations, clarifying that it was expressing no opinion on the issue and that the petitioner was at liberty to pursue remedies available under law. The matter has been directed to be listed in due course after the reopening of the High Court following the Diwali vacation.
Advocate Jogendra Thakur appeared for the petitioner. Advocates Bibhishan Sutar and Komal Punjabi represented the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation, while Assistant Government Pleader Gauri Sawant appeared for the Maharashtra government. The case is Mithila Chhath Puja Sangh v. State of Maharashtra.
Source: India Legal