LawQuorum

Home › News › Bombay High Court: Silence Cannot Justify Taking Private Land Without Legal Authority

Bombay High Court: Silence Cannot Justify Taking Private Land Without Legal Authority

29 Sept 2026 · Legal News · By The Law Quorum

The Bombay High Court's Nagpur Bench has held that a landowner's silence while the State built a road on his land cannot be treated as legal authority for taking away his property. A Bench of Justice Anil S. Kilor and Justice Rajnish R. Vyas said that unless there is material showing a lawful surrender, transfer or consent to permanent deprivation, the absence of an objection does not meet the requirement of Article 300-A of the Constitution. Article 300-A states that no person shall be deprived of his property except by authority of law.

The case involved land in Kolara (Rith), Chimur, Chandrapur, owned by the petitioner's father. The Satara-Masal road was built on this land in 1979 without any acquisition. The father died in 1998. The petitioner challenged a communication dated December 15, 2025, in which the Zilla Parishad's Executive Engineer rejected his representation for compensation, citing a delay of more than 20 years and relying on the Supreme Court's ruling in State of Maharashtra v. Digambar (1995) 4 SCC 386.

The State argued that the father had voluntarily allowed the work, which was taken up as drought relief, and that the delay and laches were unexplained. It also contended that Digambar, a three-judge Bench ruling, rendered later two-judge decisions per incuriam. The petitioner relied on official communications, including RTI material, indicating that compensation was payable. The Court noted that the State produced no document showing written consent. It held that the law recognises compulsory acquisition or acquisition by agreement, and that any such agreement must be in writing.

On Digambar, the Court clarified that it was not declaring a larger Bench decision per incuriam, and that Digambar continues to govern discretionary relief under Article 226 where delay, laches or acquiescence justify refusal. It noted that Sukh Dutt Ratra & Another vs. State of Himachal Pradesh and others (2022) 7 SCC 508 had considered Digambar and still granted relief. It rejected the State's "nil compensation" argument based on K.T. Plantation and held that the obligation to pay just and fair compensation is a constitutional consequence of compulsory deprivation.

Allowing the petition, the Court directed the respondents to initiate acquisition under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, including a Section 11 preliminary notification, and to complete it within a stipulated period. The competent authority must specifically consider the consequences of the extraordinary delay while fixing compensation. Disbursement among the legal heirs of the original owner will follow the law. No costs were awarded.

Advocate A. R. Ingole appeared for the petitioner, while P. P. Pendke, AGP, appeared for the respondent. The case is Shekhar Ghanshyam Janbandhu v. State of Maharashtra & Ors. (Neutral Citation: 2026:BHC-NAG:12657-DB).

Source: Verdictum