LawQuorum

Home › News › Calcutta High Court: Disabled Son's Maintenance Continues Past Majority, ITI Course Doesn't Prove Self-Sufficiency

Calcutta High Court: Disabled Son's Maintenance Continues Past Majority, ITI Course Doesn't Prove Self-Sufficiency

1 Oct 2026 · Legal News · By The Law Quorum

The Calcutta High Court has upheld a lower court's decision requiring a father to continue paying maintenance for his son, who suffers from a 70 per cent physical disability, even after the son attained majority. Justice Uday Kumar found no legal error in the trial court's orders and dismissed the father's challenge.

The case began in 2005, when the wife filed a maintenance claim under Section 125 of the Criminal Procedure Code for herself and her minor son, accusing her husband of neglect. In 2012, the trial court rejected her claim after finding her marriage void because the husband already had a wife. However, the court awarded ₹3,000 per month for their son, who had a physical disability. The husband's challenge to that award was dismissed by the High Court in 2016.

After the son turned 18, his mother applied under Section 127 CrPC to continue or modify the maintenance, stating that he had a 70–75 per cent orthopaedic disability and could not support himself. The husband objected, arguing that the son had completed his Higher Secondary education, done an ITI course, could move independently, and that the mother had no right to file on his behalf. The Judicial Magistrate rejected these objections, holding that a major child unable to maintain himself due to physical or mental abnormality remains entitled to maintenance under Section 125(1) CrPC, and that the mother was competent to file the application.

The High Court agreed. It noted that Section 125 imposes a social obligation on a person with sufficient means to maintain his child. While the main provision covers minors, it contains an exception for a major child—other than a married daughter—who cannot maintain himself because of physical or mental abnormality or injury. The Court said it would be wrong to assume that the obligation ends automatically when the child turns 18, or that a severely disabled person must start a fresh lawsuit from scratch.

The Court also rejected the argument that not filing an affidavit of assets and liabilities, as required by the Supreme Court's rulings in Rajnesh v. Neha and Aditi v. Jitesh Sharma, invalidated the order. It found those judgments did not apply here. The Court observed that the husband had engaged in a pattern of obstructive litigation, raising the same objections about the son's majority and the mother's locus standi that had already been rejected in March 2022, through a fresh, unverified petition in October 2022. It called this an abuse of the judicial process and said the trial court rightly imposed nominal costs of ₹500 on him.

The Court concluded that the father is legally bound to maintain his severely disabled major son as long as the disability persists and the son cannot support himself. However, Section 127 CrPC allows modification or cancellation if there is a genuine, material change in circumstances. Such a change would require concrete proof of actual financial self-sufficiency and gainful employment, not speculative assumptions based on technical milestones or vocational training. The Court found no illegality, perversity, or jurisdictional error in the trial court's orders.

Source: SCC Times