Calcutta High Court Orders Fresh Probe Into Facebook Casteist Insult Case, Says Police Can't Cite 'No Clue' Without Exhausting Cyber Protocols
The Calcutta High Court has directed further investigation into a case of casteist insult on social media, ruling that police cannot report "no clue" just because a local cyber inquiry failed to get user details from Facebook. The court said the investigating agency must exhaust specialised State CID cyber-forensic or IP-log tracking protocols before giving up.
The case began with a written complaint by a man from the Scheduled Caste community. He alleged that people from the general caste hurled foul, unparliamentary and casteist abuses targeting his caste identity, religion, God and family on Facebook. The complaint led to a case under Section 3(1)(r)/(s) of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.
Police filed a final report saying there was no clue, as assistance sought from Facebook through the Cyber Police Station in Kolkata yielded no actual user details. The petitioner then filed a protest petition. The Special Court rejected it, noting that charge sheets had been filed in three other special cases filed by the same complainant and that the "nil" report was filed after due investigation, so there was no reason to order re-investigation.
Justice Uday Kumar, hearing the matter, referred to the Supreme Court's judgment in Bhagwant Singh v. Commissioner of Police, which held that a Magistrate or Special Judge must independently evaluate a protest petition on its merits to see if cognizable material was overlooked or the investigation was perfunctory. The Bench found the Special Judge's reasoning shocking. It said criminal law examines every distinct criminal act on its own evidence, and a litigant's earlier or parallel cases can never be a legal basis to dismiss a later grievance of casteist insult on digital media. Such reasoning is perverse and contrary to basic criminal adjudication, the court added.
Referring to Vinay Tyagi v. Irshad Ali, the Bench held that the trial court's failure to direct further investigation through a higher supervisory rank, such as the Deputy Commissioner of Police or a specialised cyber cell, caused a serious miscarriage of justice. The court set aside the impugned order, quashed the acceptance of the final report and the dropping of the special case.
The matter was remanded to the Special Court, Alipore, with a direction that further investigation into Behala Police Station Case No. 274 dated 17.10.2022 be conducted under the direct supervision of the Deputy Commissioner of Police (South-West Division / Specialized Cyber Cell supervisory tier, Kolkata Police).
Source: Verdictum