Delhi High Court Judge Recuses After Lawyer Walks Out Saying 'I Cry My Beloved Justice System'
A Delhi High Court judge recused herself from a case after a lawyer repeatedly said, "I cry my beloved justice system" and walked out of the courtroom during a hearing. Justice Manmeet Pritam Singh Arora called the advocate's conduct "reckless, reprehensible and amount to misconduct" and transferred the matter to another bench.
The case involves a petition by 91-year-old Arjun Dev Bhatia, who challenged a Rohini court order that allowed his daughter-in-law to enter his house in Pitampura as alternate accommodation after she faced eviction from a rented flat in the same area. Bhatia claims to be the absolute owner of the house and told the High Court that his son and daughter-in-law stopped living with him in February 2010. The couple had been living in a rented flat since April 2013, but an eviction decree was passed against them after Bhatia's son allegedly stopped paying the monthly rent of ₹27,500.
During the hearing, the Court asked Bhatia whether he was willing to pay the monthly rent so his daughter-in-law could continue living in the rented accommodation. He agreed and offered an advance equivalent to six months' rent. However, the daughter-in-law's counsel told the Court that she had already vacated the flat and handed over the keys to the landlord. This was disputed by the lawyer representing Bhatia's son, who said his client did not wish to move back to rented accommodation.
The Court directed Bhatia to deposit six months' rent and ordered his son to deposit any outstanding rental dues. It also summoned the landlord to verify whether possession of the rented flat had been handed over.
When the lawyer repeatedly remarked, "I cry my beloved justice system" and began walking out, the Court called him back. He apologised, but Justice Arora rejected it, saying it was neither heartfelt nor genuine. The Court then directed that the matter be transferred to another bench, while stating that its interim directions to Bhatia, the landlord and the government will stand.
Senior Advocate Amit Chadha, along with advocates Mustafa Alam, Harjas, Nitin Gautam, Amit Garg, Yashima Sharma, Shahzad and Liza Paras, appeared for the petitioner father-in-law.
Source: Barandbench