LawQuorum

Home › News › Delhi High Court: Magistrate Must Hear Accused Before Taking Cognisance of Private Complaint

Delhi High Court: Magistrate Must Hear Accused Before Taking Cognisance of Private Complaint

30 Sept 2026 · Legal News · By The Law Quorum

The Delhi High Court has held that a magistrate court can take cognisance of an offence in a private complaint only after examining the complainant and the witnesses on oath and giving the accused an opportunity of hearing. A Division Bench of Justices Navin Chawla and Ravinder Dudeja said that under Section 223(1) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), the examination of the complainant and witnesses and the hearing of the accused are steps that come before cognisance is taken.

The Court also answered when a magistrate must issue notice to the accused under the first proviso to Section 223(1) of the BNSS. It said the notice must be issued after examining the complainant and the witnesses present on oath, unless exempted, and after forming a prima facie opinion that the complaint does not deserve to be dismissed under Section 226 of the BNSS but that cognisance may deserve to be taken of the offence.

The findings came while deciding references arising from two petitions. The Bench was asked to settle the stage at which cognisance is taken in a private complaint under the BNSS and when notice must be issued to the proposed accused.

After considering the arguments, the Court said that unlike Section 200 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), Section 223 of the BNSS provides that no cognisance can be taken without giving the accused an opportunity of being heard. It held that the examination of the complainant and witnesses is part of the process leading to cognisance, rather than a step occurring after cognisance as under the CrPC.

The Court rejected the argument that magistrates should have discretion to issue notice either before or after recording the complainant's statement. It held that where examination is statutorily required, notice would ordinarily have greater meaning after the statements have been recorded, enabling the proposed accused to make an effective representation.

The Court underscored that the legislature clearly wanted to depart from the earlier position under the CrPC, where the accused did not have a right to be heard at that stage and faced a prolonged trial bound to fail. The accused can now show the magistrate that even taking the complaint and the statements of the complainant and witnesses at face value, the complaint does not disclose an offence. This is the limited right now conferred on the accused, but it must be fully granted, the Court said.

Advocates Rakesh Malhotra, Bharat Malhotra, Kushal Malhotra, Abhijeet Singh and Gayatri Bhatia represented Dr Rita Bakshi. Advocates Raajan Chawla and Pooja Joshi appeared for Seema Bajaj. Additional Public Prosecutor Aman Usman with advocate Manvendra Yadav appeared for the State. Central Government Standing Counsel Amit Tiwari with advocates Ayushi Srivastava, Arpan Narwal, Kushagra Malik and Ujjwal Tyagi represented the Union of India. Senior Advocate Pavan Narang with advocates Sidhartha Das, Himanshu Sethi, Tushar Sharma, Siddharth Gautam, Kamal Nayan and Himanshu Goel appeared for Anita Rani Mehra. Senior Advocate Pavan Narang, along with advocates Smiti Verma, Pranay Chitale, Udayvir Rana and Aditya Dutta, represented Neena Kapoor.

Source: Barandbench