Delhi High Court Rejects Regularisation of Temple Built Without Sanction on Nazul Land
The Delhi High Court has refused to regularise a temple built without permission on Nazul land in Priyadarshini Vihar, and upheld the Delhi Development Authority's decision to dispose of such land only through auction. Justice Jasmeet Singh dismissed the writ petition, finding no fault with the DDA's policy.
The dispute goes back decades. The DDA had given a perpetual lease to the American Embassy Indian Employees Co-operative Housing Society for developing Priyadarshini Vihar, with two blocks — A and B — earmarked for nursery schools. The society later asked for the Block A nursery site to be allotted for a temple. In June 1987, the DDA told the society to form a separate religious society and apply afresh. The petitioner society, Sanmati Sabha, was then formed and applied for allotment in January 1988. In 1991-92, the society built a temple on the site without any change of land use or sanction from the DDA.
The DDA later approved allotment of the entire plot for the temple and a Satsang Bhawan. But in December 2017, a Division Bench of the High Court set aside that approval and directed the DDA to re-examine the allotment afresh. Following this, the DDA held a meeting in December 2021 and recorded that the earlier approval was null and void. It also noted that under the DDA (Disposal of Developed Nazul Land) Rules, 1981, as amended by a Gazette Notification of 11 March 2021, Nazul land for socio-cultural-religious categories could now be disposed of only by auction. The DDA said it had no power to regularise the unauthorised occupation.
The petitioner challenged these minutes, seeking allotment of the 926 sq. m. plot and regularisation of the temple and Satsang Bhawan. It argued that Rule 5 of the Nazul Rules allows allotment to social or charitable institutions, including for religious purposes, and offered to pay the costs of regularisation. The DDA countered that under the 2021 amendment, land was no longer allotted directly for such purposes, and that all Nazul land meant for health, education, socio-cultural and sports facilities was to be auctioned to optimise revenue. It added that the petitioner was free to take part in the auction.
The Court found no infirmity in the DDA's stand. It held that the policy decision to auction all such Nazul land, taken to optimise revenue and plan the development of Delhi, called for no interference. On the regularisation request, the Court noted that the temple had admittedly been built without sanction and contrary to the scheme for disposal of Nazul land, making it "clearly an illegal structure" that could not be allowed to continue. It also observed that the land had been allotted for a nursery school, a purpose that still subsisted, with no change of land use having taken place.
The Court said nothing prevented the petitioner from bidding in a fresh auction, under DDA's auction rules, for any other plot to run the temple. The writ petition was dismissed. The Court directed that the idols be removed from the temple by the petitioner, with all due respect and ceremonies, within four weeks from the date of the order.
Source: SCC Times