LawQuorum

Home › News › Delhi High Court Sets Aside CIC Order Asking It to List Delayed Judgments

Delhi High Court Sets Aside CIC Order Asking It to List Delayed Judgments

3 Nov 2026 · Legal News · By LawQuorum

The Delhi High Court has set aside an order of the Central Information Commission (CIC) that had asked the High Court to provide information about cases in which judgments were reserved but not pronounced even after two months had passed.

A single bench of Justice Amit Mahajan was hearing a petition challenging the CIC order, which had directed the petitioner to locate the information. The court said that while timely delivery of judgments is certainly a matter of public concern, public interest can only be considered when the information actually exists. It cannot be used to force a public authority to create information it does not hold. Advocate Priyam Mehta appeared for the petitioner.

The case began with a former judicial officer, who applied to the Public Information Officer (PIO) under the Right to Information Act, 2005, on April 2, 2009. He said that in a writ petition he had filed against the court, arguments were heard by a Division Bench presided over by Justice A.K. Sikri. He sought complete details of all cases heard by that judge, whether sitting singly or in a Division Bench, in which judgment was delivered more than two months after arguments concluded.

When no reply came within thirty days, he filed a first appeal under Section 19 of the RTI Act. The PIO then replied that such data was specifically maintained and compiled. The respondent later alleged that the information had been deliberately withheld and "may be readily available" with the Court Master or Private Secretary of the judge, the Registrar (Admn.-Judicial) and the office of the Chief Justice. The First Appellate Authority found no fault with the PIO's reply, noting that no such data was maintained, and rejected the appeal. The respondent then filed a second appeal before the CIC, which was dismissed. He then approached the High Court.

The bench reiterated that the RTI Act gives access only to information that is available and existing with a public authority. It referred to the Supreme Court's judgment in Central Board of Secondary Education v. Aditya Bandopadhyay (2011). The bench noted that providing the information sought would require the petitioner to examine the records of all cases heard by a particular judge, whether singly or in a Division Bench, calculate the time taken in each case, and prepare a fresh list. This would amount to collecting and collating information, which, as held in Aditya Bandopadhyay, a public authority is not obliged to do. The CIC itself had noted that such an exercise would be impossible, the bench said.

The bench held that the CIC's order proceeded merely on the assumption that the information "should be available" because lists are furnished to the Chief Justice as a practice. A direction under the RTI Act cannot be issued on such an assumption, it said, adding that such a practice does not by itself mean the lists are preserved year after year. Allowing the petition, the bench set aside the CIC order.

The case is titled Public Information Officer v. P.D. Gupta (Neutral Citation: 2026:DHC:9686).

Source: Verdictum