Delhi High Court Stays Arbitrator's Costs Orders Payable to Tribunal, to Examine Section 31-A Scope
The Delhi High Court has stayed two orders passed by a sole arbitrator that required the petitioners to pay costs to the Arbitral Tribunal itself. A Single Judge Bench of Justice Ajay Digpaul said the question of imposing costs payable to the tribunal, under Section 31-A of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, needed to be examined.
The petitioners were defendants in two arbitration proceedings. They challenged orders dated 3 October 2026 and 9 October 2026, in which the sole arbitrator imposed costs of ₹50,000 and ₹70,000 respectively, payable to the Arbitral Tribunal.
The dispute arose after the petitioners moved applications seeking recall or modification of earlier orders dated 29 August 2026 and 24 August 2026, which had closed their right to file statements of defence. They also sought condonation of a six-day delay in filing those statements. The tribunal allowed the recall/modification applications on costs of ₹25,000 and ₹35,000, and allowed the delay condonation applications on further costs of ₹25,000 and ₹35,000, both payable to the Arbitral Tribunal.
The petitioners argued that ordering costs payable to the Arbitral Tribunal went against Section 31-A of the Act. That provision, they said, lets the tribunal decide whether costs are payable by one party to another and how they should be paid, but does not allow the tribunal to impose costs payable to itself. They relied on Modi Dairy v. Alfa Laval (India) Ltd., 2018 SCC OnLine Bom 15984, where the Bombay High Court held that an arbitrator cannot, beyond charging fees, direct a party to pay costs to the arbitrator, including for failing to file pleadings on time or for granting more time to file them.
The Court observed that the imposition of costs on the petitioners, directed to be deposited before the Arbitral Tribunal, warranted consideration. It stayed the operation of the two impugned orders to the extent they directed the petitioners to deposit the costs with the tribunal, until the next date of hearing. The Court made clear that the arbitration proceedings before the tribunal would continue in accordance with law.
Notice was issued to the respondents, and the matter was listed for hearing on 25 November 2026. Advocates Nikhil Rajput appeared for the petitioners, while Advocate Nabab Singh appeared for the respondent.
Source: SCC Times