ECI Says Form 6 Won't Trigger Prosecution for Missing Voters, but Questions Linger
The Election Commission of India has clarified that voters whose names are missing from the draft electoral rolls published during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) can apply for fresh inclusion through Form 6. The clarification comes after the Commission earlier indicated that using the form in such cases could invite legal action.
The problem is that Form 6 is meant for first-time voters. It contains a declaration that the applicant should not have been an existing voter, along with a warning that if the applicant is found to have already been registered in an electoral roll, legal action could follow for making a false declaration. This has reportedly made people hesitant to use the form, even when Booth Level Officers suggested they do so.
In a letter dated November 3 addressed to the Chief Electoral Officers of all states and Union Territories, the Commission clarified that submitting Form 6 in such circumstances would not, by itself, amount to making a false declaration or invite prosecution under Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950. In effect, the Commission now assures applicants that no action will follow merely because they were previously registered voters.
The Congress has dismissed the clarification as "word games", arguing that it does not address what the party considers the fundamental flaws in the revision exercise. The party has alleged that the SIR process was designed to exclude voters rather than merely clean up electoral rolls.
The controversy has also reportedly exposed differences within the Commission. Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi had earlier questioned the insertion of an additional SIR-related declaration into the online Form 6 application. Their objection was that changes to a statutory form required a formal amendment and could not be introduced unilaterally by the Commission. Sandhu reportedly described the change as "unauthorised/illegal", while Joshi also raised concerns.
The revision was presented as an essential exercise to ensure clean, accurate and credible electoral rolls. Yet the process has reportedly resulted in the deletion of more than 13 crore names from electoral lists across the country, as per media reports. Even if a substantial proportion of these deletions are justified, the possibility of genuine voters being excluded through errors, procedural failures or inadequate documentation was always foreseeable.
The Commission appears to have acknowledged that the existing form is unsuitable for the circumstances created by the SIR, yet instead of correcting the form through the legally prescribed route, it has chosen to issue a circular explaining how applicants should interpret it. Questions remain over whether an administrative circular can override the statutory character of a prescribed form or neutralise a declaration that an applicant is required to make while submitting the application.
Article 326 of the Constitution establishes the principle of adult suffrage, and the statutory machinery governing electoral registration must operate in furtherance of that principle. The right to be included in an electoral roll is not a favour that the Commission extends to citizens, but an essential precondition for exercising the democratic right to vote.
Source: India Legal