Karnataka High Court Quashes Case Against 20 SDPI Leaders, Says Peaceful Protest Is a Constitutional Right
The Karnataka High Court has quashed criminal proceedings against 20 people described in the complaint as SDPI leaders, ruling that the constitutional right to hold a peaceful protest cannot be curtailed by starting criminal cases on frivolous allegations.
The case arose from a protest in Dakshina Kannada district, where the then Chief Minister was scheduled to attend a programme. According to the complaint, a group of 15 to 20 people carrying SDPI flags and black flags approached a junction on the convoy's route, raised slogans demanding the resignation of then State Minister K.S. Eshwarappa over a death the previous day, and obstructed the convoy. Police first registered offences of unlawful assembly, rioting, wrongful restraint and public nuisance. After investigation, the charge-sheet also invoked Section 353 of the IPC, which deals with assault or criminal force used to stop a public servant from doing official duties.
The petitioners moved the High Court under Section 482 of the CrPC, which lets a court step in to prevent abuse of the legal process, seeking to quash the proceedings for offences under Sections 143, 147, 341, 353 and 290 read with Section 149 of the IPC. They argued that neither the complaint nor the charge-sheet showed any assault or use of criminal force against a public servant, any act of mischief, or the ingredients of the alleged offences. The State opposed the plea, saying witness statements prima facie showed their involvement and the allegations should be tested at trial.
A Bench of Justice Rajesh Rai K found that the charge-sheet material did not show the petitioners had obstructed the Chief Minister's vehicle or tried to use criminal force to deter a public servant. There was no specific allegation of mischief either. Even taken at face value, the material showed at most an attempt to stage a protest, with no overt act establishing the alleged offences, the Court said. It noted that the statements of material witnesses, including eyewitnesses, described the petitioners as merely standing on the roadside and displaying their organisation's flags, which by itself would not amount to the offences invoked.
The Court also accepted the argument that the right to peaceful protest is guaranteed under Article 19 of the Constitution, and said such a right cannot be curtailed through criminal proceedings based on frivolous allegations. Allowing the criminal case to continue when the necessary ingredients of the offences were missing would amount to an abuse of the court's process, it held, and used its inherent power under Section 482 of the CrPC to end the proceedings.
Advocate Lethif B. appeared for the petitioners, while High Court Government Pleader Mahesha P. appeared for the State. The petition was allowed and the proceedings against all 20 petitioners were quashed.
Source: Verdictum