LawQuorum

Home › News › Karnataka High Court Sets Aside Divorce, Says Husband's False Paternity Claims and DNA Refusal Amount to Cruelty

Karnataka High Court Sets Aside Divorce, Says Husband's False Paternity Claims and DNA Refusal Amount to Cruelty

28 Oct 2026 · Legal News · By LawQuorum

The Karnataka High Court has set aside a divorce granted to a husband, holding that his reckless and unsubstantiated allegations against his wife, including denying the paternity of a child born during their marriage and refusing to undergo a DNA test, amounted to cruelty on his part.

A Division Bench of Justice M.I. Arun and Justice Raghavendra Seetharam Srivatsa ruled that the husband's conduct should have been taken into account by the Family Court when it decided his divorce petition. The couple, who are Christians, married on October 19, 2008 in Hubballi, and a son was born on December 15, 2011. The husband claimed his wife left the matrimonial home on March 28, 2011 and refused to return. The wife said she was ill-treated and driven out, and that she filed a complaint at the Mahila Police Station on April 6, 2011, after which the husband agreed in writing that she could stay at her parental home until delivery.

The husband filed his petition before the Family Court, Hubballi, on September 18, 2012, labelled as one under Section 10-A of the Indian Divorce Act, 1869, which deals with divorce by mutual consent. He alleged adultery, desertion and cruelty. By judgment dated January 25, 2017, the Family Court held adultery not proved but granted divorce on the grounds of desertion and cruelty. The wife appealed under Section 55(1) of the Act, and no one appeared for the husband at the hearing.

On desertion, the High Court said the Family Court showed a total non-application of mind, since the petition was filed about 18 months after the alleged desertion began, while Section 10(1)(ix) of the Act requires a mandatory two-year period. It held that this period was not made out even on the husband's own pleadings. On cruelty, the Court noted that Section 10(1)(x) requires cruelty causing a reasonable apprehension that living with the respondent would be harmful or injurious. It observed that the Family Court identified no particular act of cruelty by the wife, and that her single police complaint, which ended quickly, was not cruelty.

The Bench pointed out that the child was born on December 15, 2011, during the subsistence of a valid marriage, and that Section 112 of the Indian Evidence Act presumes such a child to be that of the husband. Despite this statutory presumption, the husband made baseless allegations about the child's paternity and the wife's character. The Court said this irresponsible conduct ought to have been noticed by the Family Court, which had not even adverted to this crucial aspect. It added that mental cruelty is abstract and has no direct evidence, so courts must assess the facts and circumstances holistically.

The Court held that the husband had adopted blanket denial, disowned the child despite the presumption under Section 112 of the Evidence Act, and made sweeping allegations about the wife's character. It concluded that the Family Court's findings on desertion were plainly erroneous and its discussion on cruelty was unsatisfactory, and that all relevant factors, including the husband's irresponsible deposition, disowning the child and refusal to undergo a DNA examination, ought to have featured in its judgment. Setting aside the judgment and decree of the Family Court, the Bench said there had been non-application of mind to the relevant factors.

Source: Verdictum