Kerala High Court: Possessing a Fake ISI Mark Isn't Enough to Punish; Prosecution Must Prove It Was Used
The Kerala High Court has ruled that simply having a fake ISI mark is not enough to attract punishment under the Bureau of Indian Standards Act, 1986. The prosecution must prove that the mark was actually used, the court said, while dismissing an appeal filed by the Joint Director of the Bureau of Indian Standards.
A single-judge bench of Justice A. Badharudeen upheld a magistrate's decision to acquit Mars, Veneers & Boards and its partners. The case involved offences under Sections 11(1) and 12(b) read with Section 33 of the BIS Act. The complainant and three other officials had inspected the accused persons' factory and found one roller bearing a fake ISI mark, for which no valid licence had been issued by the BIS. A spurious ISI mark was also found on the factory wall.
The magistrate, after taking cognizance and conducting a trial, acquitted the accused. The magistrate held that the prosecution had failed to prove with cogent and believable evidence that the accused had used a trade mark or ISI mark on any article, which is required to attract the offence under Section 11 read with Section 33. No finished product bearing the fake mark was produced, and the mere seizure of the roller did not prove beyond reasonable doubt that it was in working condition or capable of using the fake mark.
The complainant appealed to the High Court, arguing that mere possession of a spurious ISI mark is enough to attract the offences. The accused contended that possession of a mark for affixing on manufactured goods did not amount to an offence under the relevant sections.
The court examined the ingredients of Sections 11 and 12. Section 11 prohibits the use of a standard mark, or any colourable imitation of it, in relation to any article, process, patent title, trade mark or design, except under a licence. Section 12 bars any person from using, without the Bureau's prior permission, any name resembling the Bureau's name or containing "Indian Standard" or its abbreviation, and the same restriction applies to marks or trade marks containing those words or their abbreviations.
The court noted that both sections explicitly use the word "used". "In both Sections 11 and 12, the legislature vigilantly incorporated the word 'used' and the legislature in its wisdom never intended the word 'possess' to fasten criminal culpability on mere possession of a spurious ISI mark," the court observed. It also pointed out that no manufactured goods bearing a fake ISI mark were detected, seized or produced before the court. Only a roller, allegedly used for mixing, was taken into custody as MO 1, and the fake mark was also said to be on the wall.
Section 33 provides for punishment of imprisonment up to one year, or a fine up to ₹50,000, or both. The court concluded that the "use" of a fake ISI mark is punishable, and mere possession without evidence of its use in manufacturing goods does not attract the penal provisions.
Upholding the magistrate's decision, the court held that the prosecution failed to prove the use of any standard trade mark or ISI mark, and dismissed the appeal. The case is Bureau of Indian Standards v. Mars Veneers & Boards, decided on 14 October 2026. Advocates Manoj Ramaswamy appeared for the complainant, while K. Mohanakannan and A.R. Pravitha appeared for the accused persons.
Source: SCC Times