Madras High Court: Magistrate Can Order Residence In A House Outside His Territory Under Domestic Violence Act
The Madras High Court has held that a Magistrate hearing cases under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 can pass a residence order for a house that lies outside his own territorial limits. The reason: any order made under the Act can be enforced anywhere in India under Section 27(2) of the law.
The court explained that when it comes to jurisdiction, what matters is where the aggrieved woman or the respondent lives, works or runs a business, or where the cause of action arose. The location of the house itself is not relevant. Justice S. Sounthar, hearing the case, said a plain reading of Section 27(2) makes clear that a Magistrate's order is enforceable throughout India, so he is entitled to grant a residence order for a home outside his territorial limits.
The ruling came on a plea by a husband and his parents. The wife, married in 2013, had lived with her husband in their matrimonial home in Bengaluru. She alleged harassment and domestic violence and filed a case before the Judicial Magistrate, Additional Mahila Court, Krishnagiri, in Tamil Nadu, against her husband and parents-in-law, seeking residence and protection orders. The Magistrate held she was entitled to a residence order for the Bengaluru house and passed a protection order under Sections 18 and 19 of the DV Act, restraining the husband and in-laws from harassing her by words and acts. Her request for maintenance was turned down.
The husband and in-laws appealed, but the Additional Sessions Judge in Krishnagiri dismissed their appeals. They then moved the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution. Before the High Court, they argued only on jurisdiction, claiming that since the house is in Bengaluru, outside the Magistrate's territorial limits, the residence order was without jurisdiction. The wife countered that under Section 27(2) of the DV Act, a Magistrate's order is enforceable throughout India, so there was no jurisdictional error.
The court drew a distinction between Section 14 of the Criminal Procedure Code and Section 27 of the DV Act. It noted that Section 14 of the CrPC only defines a Judicial Magistrate's local jurisdiction, while a Magistrate's power to pass protection or other orders under the DV Act flows from Section 27 of that Act. In other words, the CrPC provision deals with territorial limits, whereas the DV Act provision deals with the Magistrate's power over the subject matter under the 2005 law. Under Section 27(1), the court noted, a Magistrate can entertain a complaint and pass orders if the aggrieved person or the respondent resides, carries on business or is employed within his limits, or if the cause of action arose there. Since the wife lived within the Krishnagiri Magistrate's territorial limits, he had jurisdiction to hear her complaint.
Finding no jurisdictional error or infirmity in the Magistrate's order, the court rejected the petitioners' argument and dismissed the revision petitions. There was no order as to costs.
Source: Verdictum