Madras High Court Orders Father to Return 2.5-Year-Old Son to Mother, Says Custody Can't Be Taken by Force
The Madras High Court has ordered a man to return his two-and-a-half-year-old son to the child's mother, saying that custody of a minor cannot be taken by force.
The court was hearing a Habeas Corpus Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution. The mother had asked the court to direct the police to produce her son, who she said was in the illegal custody of the father. A bench of Justice A.D. Jagadish Chandira and Justice B. Karthikeyan noted that while the father is the natural guardian of the child, who is just about two and a half years old, custody cannot be taken by force and must be sought according to the procedure established by law. The bench then directed the father to hand over the child to the mother.
The petitioner, a medical doctor, said she married the man in 2021 in Puducherry and they had two children. She alleged that she faced verbal and physical abuse and harassment from her husband. During their matrimonial disputes, she claimed, he threatened her with an aruval. She left the matrimonial home with her children and began living with her mother. According to her, the husband came to her parental home and forcibly took away the minor child without her consent. She filed a complaint with the police, and a case was registered. When no further action followed, she moved the court with the habeas corpus petition.
The bench observed that matrimonial disputes were pending between the couple and they were living separately. The mother was staying with her mother when the husband allegedly came there and forcibly took the child. Holding that custody of the minor child cannot be taken by force, the bench directed the father to return the child to the mother.
The court closed the petition with a clarification: the observations in the order are limited to the disposal of this habeas corpus petition and will not influence any future proceedings initiated by either party before the appropriate forum.
Source: Verdictum