Orissa High Court: Deity Not Exempt from Adverse Possession Claim Despite 'Perpetual Minor' Status
The Orissa High Court ruled that the description of a deity as a perpetual minor does not, by itself, prevent a claim based on adverse possession, meaning a deity is not exempt from the law of limitation for this reason alone.
The court disagreed with the Trial Court and the First Appellate Court, which had held that adverse possession could never be asserted against a deity’s property. However, the High Court upheld the lower courts' decision to dismiss the suit on a separate ground.
This ground was that the plaintiff’s family had cultivated the land under annual lease agreements and paid 'bhag,' which the court found constituted permissive possession.
The High Court dismissed the second appeal, clarifying that this dismissal is not a decree for eviction and does not grant the right to dispossess the appellants except through the legal procedures.
Justice Sanjeeb K Panigrahi observed that the notion that a deity is a perpetual minor and adverse possession can never operate against its property cannot be accepted in absolute terms. The court noted that the Supreme Court had previously rejected the idea that a deity is exempt from limitation simply because it is described as a perpetual minor.
Despite this finding, the High Court affirmed the lower courts' judgments. It found that the continuity of cultivation is not the same as the continuity of hostile possession, and the plaintiff failed to establish the commencement of hostile possession or conduct that rejected the deity’s title for the required prescriptive period.
Source: Verdictum