LawQuorum

Home › News › Punjab and Haryana High Court: 28-Week-Old Foetus Is a Child, Enhances Compensation for Unborn's Death in Accident

Punjab and Haryana High Court: 28-Week-Old Foetus Is a Child, Enhances Compensation for Unborn's Death in Accident

6 Nov 2026 · Legal News · By LawQuorum

The Punjab and Haryana High Court has ruled that a 28-week-old foetus must be treated as a child, and has granted enhanced compensation to a couple for the death of their unborn child in a motor accident. The court was hearing an appeal by the parents against a Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Panchkula, order that had dismissed their claim petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.

The accident dates back to 1997. The couple was returning home from PGI on a motorcycle when they reached near Bitta Petrol Pump on the Chandigarh-Panchkula road. Due to a blockage, the husband parked the motorcycle on the kacha portion of the road. His wife got down and started walking ahead to check the passage. The driver of a scooter came from behind and struck her, dragging her eight to ten feet. She hit a cement pipe lying on the road and got stuck between the scooter and the pipe. The woman, who was 28 weeks pregnant, suffered multiple injuries, including fractures, and the unborn child died due to the injuries.

The Tribunal had found that the accident was caused by the rash and negligent driving of the scooter driver. However, it dismissed the claim for compensation for the loss of the foetus, relying on a 1996 Himachal Pradesh High Court judgment in Rakesh Kumar v. Prem Lal, which held that such a claim was not maintainable.

Justice Parmod Goyal, sitting as a Single Bench, held that the foetus was 28 weeks old and had to be treated as a child. The court noted that the Himachal Pradesh High Court judgment relied on by the Tribunal had been specifically dealt with by a Full Bench of the Kerala High Court in Abhulasees, P.P. and others v. Abdumanaf and others. Therefore, the Tribunal erred in not granting compensation for the death of the unborn child due to the injuries suffered by the mother, the court said.

On quantum, the Bench held that in the case of a minor child, notional income must be determined as per minimum wages, and 40% future prospects must be added for calculating loss of dependency. Since the deceased was an unborn child, the court found a multiplier of '9' appropriate for determining loss of earning capacity. It also held that a 50% deduction was required towards personal expenses of the deceased, who was survived by his parents. The court awarded Rs 15,000 towards loss of estate and Rs 15,000 towards funeral expenses. Each parent was also entitled to Rs 40,000 towards filial consortium. The total compensation awarded in appeal will carry 7.5% interest from the date of filing the claim petition till realization, except for the conventional heads of loss of consortium, funeral expenses, and loss of estate.

Advocate A. S. Virk represented the appellants, while Advocate Raj Kumar appeared for the respondent. The case is titled Suresh Kumar Sethi and Anr v. Sanjeev Kumar and Ors.

Source: Verdictum