LawQuorum

Home › News › Punjab and Haryana High Court Calls Punjab Tree Law 'Draconian', State Agrees to Hold It in Abeyance

Punjab and Haryana High Court Calls Punjab Tree Law 'Draconian', State Agrees to Hold It in Abeyance

7 Nov 2026 · Legal News · By LawQuorum

The Punjab and Haryana High Court has described Punjab's new environment law as "draconian", and the state government has agreed to keep the legislation in abeyance while the matter remains pending. The bench of Chief Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra and Justice Rohit Kapoor was particularly concerned about a provision for deemed permission, under which permission to fell trees is treated as granted if an officer fails to decide an application within a set time, following payment of prescribed charges. The Court said this could devastate the state's remaining green cover.

The case began in December 2025, when Mohali resident Praneet Kaur approached the High Court challenging the proposed felling of 251 mature trees in SAS Nagar, Mohali. The trees were to be removed for the construction of roundabouts and rotaries at different junctions along the PR-7 road by the Greater Mohali Area Development Authority (GMADA). The petition questioned the decision to auction the right to cut the trees and argued that infrastructure development could not be pursued by disregarding the environmental consequences.

On December 24, 2025, a division bench led by the then Chief Justice Sheel Nagu and Justice Sanjiv Berry prohibited the felling of trees anywhere in Punjab, irrespective of their age or species, without the Court's permission until further orders. The Court relied on figures from the India State of Forest Report, 2023, which showed forest and tree cover accounted for just 3.67 percent of Punjab's geographical area and 3.65 percent of Haryana's. These were well below the national average of 25.17 percent and the 33 percent benchmark envisaged under the National Forest Policy, 1988. The Court noted that Punjab's forest cover was even lower than Rajasthan's reported figure of 4.87 percent.

The intervention was later extended to Haryana as applications seeking permission for tree felling continued to come before the Court. Because a blanket restriction created practical difficulties for routine work such as road widening and essential public infrastructure projects, the Court prepared detailed guidelines for authorities dealing with tree-felling permission applications, seeking to balance development needs with environmental responsibility.

It was against this background that the Punjab government enacted the Punjab Protection of Trees Act, 2026, on September 24, replacing the Trees Preservation Policy for Non-Forest Government and Public Lands, 2024. On paper, the law set up a regulatory framework: applications would be examined by designated Tree Protection Officers, with provisions for prescribed charges, compensatory plantations and penalties for violations. But its most contentious feature was the deemed permission clause. Under the legislation, an officer must decide an ordinary tree-felling application within 30 days, and applications concerning dead or fallen trees within seven days. Failure to decide within the stipulated period would mean permission is deemed granted.

The petitioners argued that this provision weakens the safeguards available under the earlier policy, especially when government agencies themselves may be seeking permission to fell trees for their projects. The Court questioned the mechanism, indicated its willingness to examine the merits of the legislation, and asked the state to reconsider its provisions. After the observations on October 31, the Punjab government's counsel told the bench that the law would not be implemented while the proceedings remained pending.

Source: India Legal