LawQuorum

Home › News › Son Has No Birthright in Father's Property Under Hindu Succession Act: MP High Court

Son Has No Birthright in Father's Property Under Hindu Succession Act: MP High Court

5 Nov 2026 · Legal News · By LawQuorum

The Madhya Pradesh High Court has ruled that a son does not have a birthright in his father's property under the Hindu Succession Act. A son gets a share only after the father's death, not during his lifetime, the court said.

A single bench of Justice Ashish Shroti made the observation while dismissing an appeal filed by sons in a property dispute. The appellants had challenged a judgment of the First Additional District Judge, which had dismissed their suit seeking declaration of title, possession and a permanent injunction.

The court said that after the Hindu Succession Act came into force, the theory of birthright does not exist. It added that only if a coparcener was born before the Act came into force would the property devolve by survivorship upon the surviving members of the coparcenary, as provided under Section 6 of the Act.

The dispute involved ancestral land recorded in the name of the first defendant and his brothers. The plaintiffs—the first defendant's wife and their two sons—claimed the property was ancestral and that they had rights in it since birth. They alleged the father had threatened to sell the land and not give them any share, and they feared this would extinguish their rights. The trial court dismissed the suit, holding that after Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act came into force, the concept of birthright in ancestral property does not exist, and the plaintiffs could not claim any right during the father's lifetime. The first appellate court upheld that decision.

The High Court noted that the wife, being the first defendant's spouse, could not be considered a coparcener. Only the sons would fall in that category, the bench said. It also noted that the plaintiffs were born after the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, came into force. The bench referred to the Supreme Court's judgment in Uttam vs. Saubhag Singh (2013), which held that upon the death of an ancestor after the enforcement of the Hindu Succession Act, there is a deemed partition by operation of law immediately before his death, and the property ceases to be joint family property. The successors then become tenants-in-common, not joint family members.

The bench further observed that the plaintiffs themselves stated in their plaint that their father had received the suit land in a partition from his father. This meant the property became the father's self-acquired property on partition. Consequently, during the father's lifetime, the plaintiffs could not claim any share in it. The High Court upheld the appellate court's judgment and dismissed the appeal.

The case was titled Prembai and Others v. Ramswaroop and Others (Second Appeal No. 264 of 2015). Advocate Ashish Shrivastava appeared for the appellants, while Government Advocate Rajendra Jain represented the respondent.

Source: Verdictum