Sonia Gandhi's Memoir and Grandson Raihan Vadra's Photo Show: Two Stories of Refusing to Budge
Two members of the Gandhi family are in the news at the same time — Sonia Gandhi, for her forthcoming memoir, and her grandson Raihan Vadra, for a photo exhibition in Delhi that was cut short.
Sonia's book, Belonging: A Journey of Love, describes her Greek restaurant meeting with Rajiv Gandhi, whom she later married, and traces her life from childhood through her marriage, making India her home, and the deaths of her mother-in-law Indira Gandhi and her husband Rajiv. The publisher, Penguin Random House India, wanted certain portions reworked, which Sonia refused. The portions in question were references to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the RSS and communal tensions. The Congress alleged pressure from the Modi government, while the publishers denied this, saying points raised during a "normal editorial process" ended without an understanding over a "particular issue". Sonia withdrew from Penguin Random House and signed with HarperCollins. The book is due for release on November 10.
Raihan Vadra's solo exhibition, titled "No idea is final", was scheduled for October at Bikaner House in New Delhi. It opened but was cut short after the management asked him to remove what it saw as objectionable pictures. Of the roughly 100 pictures on display, 70 were removed. The show included wildlife photographs, abstract works and images of recent youth movements. Raihan said he was asked to remove two photographs of the Indian flag and refused.
In an Instagram post, Raihan said the Bikaner House management forced him to remove the bulk of the artworks, which included photos of youth protests in Delhi, calling the content "objectionable". He said he was directed to move two photos of the Tiranga and refused, adding he would not take down a picture of the Indian flag. According to him, the management objected because the protest photos were "political" and gave him a choice: remove the photos or face cancellation of the show. Raihan said the photos merely documented recent events and that it was his duty as an Indian artist to document what was going on.
The Bikaner House management said the photographs were "found to be inconsistent" with the venue's policy. Raihan's father, Robert Vadra, told the media that hours before the exhibition was to open, Raihan was asked to remove the majority of the photographs. Raihan described it as "three years of my hard work". His mother, Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, called the move "ridiculous" and said it was an attempt to muzzle the voice of the youth, adding that nothing was derogatory towards anyone and the photos were "just a visual documentation of the protest".
The BJP has also weighed in, saying Raihan included political photographs much later and that his initial proposal had no mention of political content. BJP spokesperson Pradeep Bhandari claimed a rift between Rahul Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi Vadra on the grounds that Rahul had not defended his nephew, and said Priyanka was seeking to "soft-launch" her son. Rahul had not posted anything on the controversy at the time.
Source: India Legal