LawQuorum

Home › News › Supreme Court Allows Sale of Flats on Disputed Property, Buyers Must Be Told of Pending Suits

Supreme Court Allows Sale of Flats on Disputed Property, Buyers Must Be Told of Pending Suits

6 Nov 2026 · Legal News · By LawQuorum

The Supreme Court has allowed a developer to sell flats built on a disputed property, ruling that such sales can go ahead as long as buyers are told about the pending litigation. A Bench of Justices B.V. Nagarathna and R. Mahadevan set aside a restriction imposed by the Calcutta High Court and permitted the appellant to create third-party rights in the constructed flats.

The Calcutta High Court, in its order dated 3 August 2023, had allowed the appellant to continue construction according to a previously sanctioned plan. However, it restrained the appellant, his agents, partners and anyone acting under him from using the property, creating any third-party interest, or transferring it without the permission of the competent civil court. The appellant challenged this direction in the Supreme Court.

The appellant argued that construction was already complete and the flats were ready for sale. He contended that Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, permits the transfer of a disputed property subject to the outcome of a pending suit. He also said that the suits filed by him and by Respondents 5 and 6 were pending and had been clubbed together, and that the proceedings were moving very slowly, with Respondents 5 and 6 seeking adjournments. The respondents opposed the appeal, saying that because the title was in dispute, the appellant should not be allowed to create third-party interests in the property.

The Supreme Court noted that the construction was already complete and that third parties were ready and willing to purchase the flats, subject to the result of the pending suit and the risks involved. It therefore set aside paragraph 14 of the High Court order, which had restrained the appellant from creating third-party interests or transferring the property without the leave of the civil court.

While removing the restriction, the Court made clear that any sale or creation of third-party rights would remain subject to the outcome of the suits filed by the appellant and Respondents 5 and 6. It also directed the appellant to state the pendency of the suits in the sale agreement or sale deed executed in favour of third parties. Noting that the suits had been pending since 2022, the Court asked the trial court to dispose of them as expeditiously as possible, with the cooperation of the parties.

Source: SCC Times