LawQuorum

Home › News › Supreme Court Quashes NSA Detention in Sambhal Violence Case, Fines UP ₹10 Lakh

Supreme Court Quashes NSA Detention in Sambhal Violence Case, Fines UP ₹10 Lakh

30 Sept 2026 · Legal News · By The Law Quorum

The Supreme Court has quashed a preventive detention order under the National Security Act, 1980 (NSA) against an accused in the Sambhal communal violence case, and imposed exemplary costs of ₹10 lakh on the State of Uttar Pradesh.

The case relates to communal violence in Sambhal that broke out after a court-ordered survey of the Shahi Jama Masjid, in which four people died. The appellant was arrested about 54 days after the incident, allegedly on the basis of a custodial confession recorded by investigating authorities. In September 2025, he was granted bail. However, while he remained in judicial custody in connection with other FIRs, the detaining authority passed the detention order under Section 3(2) of the NSA.

The appellant submitted a representation against the order from district jail, which was rejected on the ground of delay. Representations to the State Government and the Central Government were also rejected.

A Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu held that while a detaining authority may rely on other independent material, a confessional statement made to a police officer, without any substantive grounds or corroborative evidence, cannot be the sole basis for a detention order. The Court said it had examined the reply affidavit and written submissions of the respondents and found no denial of the appellant's claim that he was subjected to torture and threats of death and made the confession under that compulsion. Therefore, the confession could not be seen as voluntary.

The Court reiterated that protection against self-incrimination is a fundamental right of paramount constitutional significance, reflected in Section 23 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA). It noted that a confession made before a police officer is presumed to be tainted by coercion, threat, inducement or promise, and that the BSA recognises only two limited exceptions: a confession before a magistrate in accordance with law, or one that leads to the discovery of a fact to the extent permitted by law. A police confession is not regarded as trustworthy evidence and is generally excluded against its maker, the Court said.

On the second issue, the Court found no material on record to substantiate the existence of certain communications. It observed that the detaining authority appeared to have proceeded on the footing that the filing of the chargesheet confirmed the appellant's involvement in the incident, including the alleged murders, and thereby established a disturbance of public order. The Court also observed that the State must remain faithful to the rationale underlying preventive detention, and that using it merely to defeat bail granted in underlying criminal cases turns the legal process into punishment.

Advocate Divyesh Pratap Singh appeared for the appellant, while Additional Solicitor General KM Natraj appeared for the respondents.

Source: Verdictum