Supreme Court Quashes NSA Detention of Sambhal Violence Accused Mulla Afroz, Fines UP ₹10 Lakh
The Supreme Court has quashed the preventive detention order passed against Mulla Afroz, the alleged mastermind of the November 2024 Sambhal violence, under the National Security Act (NSA), 1980. The court also imposed costs of ₹10 lakh on the State of Uttar Pradesh for passing what it called an illegal detention order.
A Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu held that a confessional statement cannot be the sole ground for an order under the preventive detention law. The Bench also found that the detaining authority had not given appropriate consideration to the facts of the case, and concluded that the power of preventive detention was illegally exercised.
"We quash the detention order, set aside the judgment of the High Court, and impose costs of ₹10 lakh on the State of Uttar Pradesh for passing the illegal detention order," the Court held. Advocate Divyesh Pratap Singh appeared for the Appellant, while Additional Solicitor General KM Natraj appeared for the Respondents.
The case arose from communal violence in Sambhal that followed a court-ordered survey of the Shahi Jama Masjid, in which four people died. The Appellant was arrested about 54 days after the incident, allegedly on the basis of a custodial confession recorded by the investigating authorities. He was arrested by police from Nakhasa police station, Sambhal, in January 2025.
Although the Appellant was later granted bail by the Allahabad High Court, the District Magistrate issued a preventive detention order against him on October 13, 2025, under Section 3 of the National Security Act, 1980. The Allahabad High Court affirmed that order, prompting the Appellant to file a Special Leave Petition before the Supreme Court.
The Appellant contended that neither the detention order nor the grounds of detention were provided to him. A letter from the District Magistrate to the Superintendent of District Jail, Moradabad, indicated that the detention order and grounds of detention, along with related documents, had not been received by the Superintendent, who was directed to read over and explain them to the Appellant.
The High Court, while dismissing the plea, had held that there was due application of mind by the detaining authority and the State Government, that the grounds of detention were well informed and cited details of acts affecting public order, and that the possibility of the detenu repeating such acts had been recorded. Setting aside the High Court's findings, the Supreme Court allowed the appeal.
The Court also expressed deep sorrow over the death of a law clerk days before his 27th birthday, and dedicated the judgment to him. The case is titled Mulla Afroz v. Union of India and Ors. [Crl.A. No. 004310 / 2026].
Source: Verdictum