LawQuorum

Home › News › Supreme Court Refuses to Supervise Arbitral Award Execution, Asks Law Commission to Study Enforcement Framework

Supreme Court Refuses to Supervise Arbitral Award Execution, Asks Law Commission to Study Enforcement Framework

29 Oct 2026 · Legal News · By LawQuorum

The Supreme Court has ruled that it cannot be asked, through a clarification plea, to supervise execution proceedings pending before another court. It held that its jurisdiction over a certified question of law ends once that question is answered.

Dismissing a Miscellaneous Application and disposing of an appeal against a Delhi High Court interim order, the Court said it is for the executing court, and the appellate court above it, to decide questions that arise during execution. A Bench of Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta and Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh observed that the Court cannot assume a supervisory role over continuing execution proceedings or adjudicate every issue arising in them.

The Court also requested the Law Commission of India to undertake a focused study of the framework governing enforcement and execution of arbitral awards. It said the study could identify practical impediments to timely recovery, examine the experience of other jurisdictions, and consider whether domestic and foreign arbitral awards need separate enforcement procedures or a common framework with safeguards.

In an epilogue, the Court expressed concern that the parties were still litigating enforcement more than twenty-four years after the award. It observed that an arbitral regime must be measured by whether the successful party can realise the award's fruits within a reasonable time, and flagged asset disclosure, coordination of execution modes, repetitive objections and delay as matters needing scrutiny.

The appellant, Royal Construction Company Pvt. Ltd., is the award-holder under an arbitral award dated August 10, 2002, with amounts denominated in Iraqi Dinars. The respondent, National Projects Construction Corporation, is the award-debtor. By its judgment of February 24, 2015, the Supreme Court restored the award's directions, stressing minimal judicial intervention.

In execution, a Single Judge of the Delhi High Court directed on July 26, 2017 that the award-debtor could discharge its liability in Indian currency at the exchange rate on the date of the underlying agreement. On December 17, 2019, the Division Bench set this aside and certified a substantial question of law under Articles 134-A and 133(1)(a) on the relevant date for conversion. On October 10, 2023, the Supreme Court answered the question in the negative, holding that no occasion arose to fix a conversion date.

While execution continued, the respondent contended that the principal had been paid in 2009 under High Court orders. On February 16, 2026, the High Court granted the parties liberty to seek clarification from the Supreme Court. The Court held that it erred in appreciating the scope of the earlier adjudication. Its jurisdiction was confined to the certified question, and it did not examine factual matters such as amounts deposited and later withdrawn. Once the question was answered, the scope of the earlier proceedings stood exhausted, and it would be impermissible to enlarge it with questions distinct from and unconnected with the lis.

The Court disposed of the appeal and dismissed the Miscellaneous Application, leaving the award-debtor at liberty to raise all objections on adjustment or set-off before the executing court. It requested the Law Commission to study the framework and make recommendations, and directed the Registry to forward a copy of the judgment to the Commission's Chairman.

Advocate Rishabh Sancheti appeared for the appellant and Vikramjit Banerjee, Additional Solicitor General, appeared for the respondent.

Source: Verdictum