LawQuorum

Home › News › Supreme Court Rules 24-Hour Detention Clock Starts When Liberty is Curtailed, Not When Arrest Memo is Prepared

Supreme Court Rules 24-Hour Detention Clock Starts When Liberty is Curtailed, Not When Arrest Memo is Prepared

14 Nov 2026 · Legal News · By LawQuorum

In the case of Sujit Das versus Union of India, the Supreme Court clarified a key constitutional safeguard regarding detention. The Court held that the 24-hour clock, as guaranteed under Article 22(2) of the Constitution, starts when a person's freedom is curtailed, regardless of what the paperwork states.

This ruling addresses a practice where investigating agencies could delay the formal arrest and the preparation of an arrest memo. In a specific incident, officers intercepted a truck and a motorcycle in Tripura on September 29, 2025, and detained the occupants. The search concluded at 5 pm, but the formal arrests were recorded the following morning at 11 am. This created an 18-hour gap between the end of the search and the first formal arrest.

The Customs Department had argued that the time spent searching and recording statements was merely a temporary restraint and should not count toward the 24-hour limit. However, the Supreme Court bench of Justices Ujjal Bhuyan and Atul S Chandurkar rejected this argument, stating there is no such thing as a 'temporary disruption of liberty' that falls outside the constitutional clock.

The judgment established that both the terms 'arrested' and 'detained' in Article 22(2) carry the same constitutional weight because the Constitution does not recognize detention without arrest. Therefore, if a person is not free to leave, they are in custody, irrespective of the official documentation.

Furthermore, the Court emphasized that the 24-hour deadline is not just a maximum limit but also requires that the duration of detention within that period must be reasonable. The Court found the 18-hour unexplained gap in the Tripura case to be unreasonable on its own. The judgment also places a duty on magistrates to record the exact date and time of detention and verify if the 24-hour limit has been met, ensuring that remand is not a mechanical process.

Source: India Legal