Trial Court Must Weigh Cross-Examination Before Summoning Accused Under Section 319 CrPC: Supreme Court
The Supreme Court has ruled that a trial court cannot ignore a witness's cross-examination while using its power under Section 319 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC) to summon an additional accused. Section 319 CrPC allows a court to add a person as an accused during trial if evidence shows they were involved in the crime.
The bench of Justice Manoj Misra and Justice NK Singh said that while the power under Section 319 CrPC can be invoked based only on a witness's chief examination, once that witness has been cross-examined, the court must look at the testimony as a whole. The court explained that evidence is not just the statement-in-chief but also includes what the witness says during cross-examination.
The ruling came in an appeal against a judgment of the Allahabad High Court, which had dismissed a revision petition filed by the appellant. The revision petition challenged a trial court order summoning the appellant under Section 319 CrPC to face trial along with other accused. The case arose from an FIR registered under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, alleging that one Raman Yadav and the appellant went to the informant's house and demanded a share from the deceased father. When the deceased refused to execute the transfer instrument, the appellant held the deceased's hand, and Raman Singh stabbed him with a knife. Both then fled.
The appellant argued that the trial court had mechanically exercised its power under Section 319 CrPC without considering the full depositions of the witnesses. It was submitted that during cross-examination, a witness had said he had not personally seen anyone attack his father and that the FIR was not lodged on the day of the incident but later on the insistence of villagers. The respondents contended that at this stage the court was not required to hold a mini trial to decide whether the evidence would lead to a conviction, but only to be satisfied that the additional accused should be tried along with the existing ones.
The Supreme Court observed that one purpose of the power under Section 319 CrPC is to ensure that a person involved in a crime does not escape the law due to lapses by the investigating agency. However, it added that this power must be used sparingly, based on the evidence led during trial. The bench said that if a witness's cross-examination demolishes the foundation of his chief examination, the trial court cannot overlook the statement as a whole when the decision to arraign an additional accused rests entirely on that statement. After considering the entire testimony, it would still be for the trial court to decide whether to summon the additional accused.
The court concluded that neither the High Court nor the trial court had considered the depositions in their entirety and had overlooked the relevant witness's cross-examination. It allowed the appeal and set aside the impugned orders. The case was titled Neelam Yadav v. State of U.P. & Anr. [SLP (Crl.) No. 5531/2026]. Advocate Lavish appeared for the appellant, while Advocate Ashish Kumar Rai appeared for the respondents.
Source: Verdictum