Wife's Wish for Husband to Live as Gharjamai Is Not Cruelty, Jharkhand High Court Rules
The Jharkhand High Court has upheld a Family Court order refusing to grant a man divorce, ruling that a wife's mere wish for her husband to live as a Gharjamai — a man who lives in his wife's parental home — does not amount to cruelty under the Hindu Marriage Act.
A bench of Justice Sujit Narayan Prasad and Justice Sanjay Prasad was hearing an appeal against a Family Court judgment that had dismissed the husband's suit seeking divorce under Section 13(1)(i-a) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, on the ground of cruelty. Advocate Shekhar Prasad Gupta appeared for the appellant-husband, while Amicus Curiae Atanu Banerjee represented the respondent-wife.
The couple's married life began peacefully, but the husband alleged that after a few days his wife started going to Patna. According to him, her parents wanted him to leave his own parents and live with them in Patna. He refused, as his parents were old and ailing. The wife, he said, went to Patna in 2013 and never returned to the matrimonial home, insisting that he leave his parents and live as a Gharjamai. The husband claimed this caused him tremendous mental pressure and social stigma, and he sought divorce on grounds of cruelty.
The bench explained that cruelty in matrimonial law means conduct so grave and weighty that one spouse cannot reasonably be expected to live with the other. It must be more serious than the ordinary wear and tear of married life, and serious enough to convince the court that the relationship has deteriorated to the point where living together without mental agony has become impossible. Cruelty can take many forms, the bench said, and must create a fear in the other spouse's mind that living with the erring party is dangerous.
The bench noted that the Principal Judge of the Family Court had concluded that visiting one's parental house is as good as a right for every bride and cannot be termed cruelty for divorce. The High Court agreed, stating that the Family Judge had rightly observed that visiting the parental house is a bride's right and that the wife's mere wish for her husband to live as a Gharjamai would not constitute cruelty under the Hindu Marriage Act, nor could it be termed cruelty for divorce "at any stretch of imagination."
Finding that the cruelty alleged by the husband could not be proved, the bench refused to interfere with the Family Court's judgment and dismissed the appeal.
Source: Verdictum